Algebra · real student question

Show that kt + xy > ky + tx is equivalent to (k - x)(t - y) > 0.

Question

Show that

kt+xy>ky+txkt+xy>ky+tx

is equivalent to a single product being positive, and state the condition.

Step-by-step solution

  1. Move everything to one side. Subtract kyky and txtx from both sides so the comparison is against zero:

    kttx+xyky>0kt-tx+xy-ky>0

  2. Group the terms in pairs sharing a factor. The first two share tt, the last two share yy:

    t(kx)+y(xk)>0t(k-x)+y(x-k)>0

  3. Make the two brackets identical. The second bracket is the negative of the first, since xk=(kx)x-k=-(k-x):

    t(kx)y(kx)>0t(k-x)-y(k-x)>0

    Spotting this sign flip is the whole trick; without it the grouping looks like a dead end.

  4. Factor out the common binomial.

    (kx)(ty)>0(k-x)(t-y)>0

  5. State the condition and check it. A product of two reals is positive exactly when both are positive or both are negative:

    (k>x and t>y)or(k<x and t<y)\left(k>x\ \text{and}\ t>y\right)\quad\text{or}\quad\left(k<x\ \text{and}\ t<y\right)

    Test k=4,t=3,x=1,y=2k=4,t=3,x=1,y=2 (both differences positive): left =12+2=14=12+2=14, right =8+3=11=8+3=11, and 14>1114>11 \checkmark, with (3)(1)=3>0(3)(1)=3>0 \checkmark. Test k=1,t=3,x=4,y=2k=1,t=3,x=4,y=2 (mixed signs): left =3+8=11=3+8=11, right =2+12=14=2+12=14, so the inequality fails \checkmark, matching (3)(1)=3<0(-3)(1)=-3<0.

Answer

kt+xy>ky+tx    (kx)(ty)>0kt+xy>ky+tx\iff(k-x)(t-y)>0

Need to solve a different problem like this? Open the solver →