Calculus · real student question

Evaluate the triple integral of -5x + 5yz over the region E where 1 <= x <= 2, 0 <= y <= 5 - 5x, and 0 <= z <= -x - 2y - 5.

Question

Evaluate the triple integral

E(5x+5yz)dV,E={(x,y,z)1x2, 0y55x, 0zx2y5}.\iiint_E (-5x+5yz)\,dV,\qquad E=\{(x,y,z)\mid 1\le x\le 2,\ 0\le y\le 5-5x,\ 0\le z\le -x-2y-5\}.

Step-by-step solution

  1. Notice the limits are degenerate, and decide what that means. For xx in (1,2](1,2] the stated upper yy-limit 55x5-5x is negative, so it lies below the lower limit 00; the same happens for zz, whose upper limit x2y5-x-2y-5 is negative. The region as written is empty as a solid, so the problem is to be read as the iterated integral with those limits, where a reversed range contributes with the opposite sign.

  2. Integrate in z. With Z=x2y5Z=-x-2y-5, 0Z(5x+5yz)dz=5xZ+5y2Z2\int_0^{Z}(-5x+5yz)\,dz=-5xZ+\frac{5y}{2}Z^2. Substituting and expanding gives 10y3+10xy2+50y2+52x2y+35xy+1252y+5x2+25x10y^3+10xy^2+50y^2+\frac52x^2y+35xy+\frac{125}{2}y+5x^2+25x.

  3. Integrate in y from 0 to 5 - 5x. Antidifferentiating and substituting the (negative) upper limit gives the outer integrand 1412512x4202003x3+284252x2392503x+5312512\frac{14125}{12}x^4-\frac{20200}{3}x^3+\frac{28425}{2}x^2-\frac{39250}{3}x+\frac{53125}{12}.

  4. Antidifferentiate in x. \int of that quartic is 282512x550503x4+94752x3196253x2+5312512x\frac{2825}{12}x^5-\frac{5050}{3}x^4+\frac{9475}{2}x^3-\frac{19625}{3}x^2+\frac{53125}{12}x.

  5. Evaluate from x = 1 to x = 2. The difference of the antiderivative at the endpoints is 252=12.5\frac{25}{2}=12.5. The result is positive even though the integrand 5x+5yz-5x+5yz is negative for much of the range, because the two reversed orientations flip the sign twice.

  6. Numerical check. Evaluating the same iterated integral numerically (with the reversed inner ranges kept as written) returns 12.50000012.500000, matching 252\frac{25}{2}.

  7. Contrast with a common wrong value. A frequently seen worked solution reports 4062572564.2-\frac{40625}{72}\approx -564.2; that value does not survive the numerical check, so the sign handling of the reversed limits must be done carefully.

Answer

252=12.5\frac{25}{2}=12.5

Need to solve a different problem like this? Open the solver →