Algebra · real student question

Given −2 < a < 1 and 1 < b < 2, which are correct? A: −4 < a − b < 0. B: −2 < ab < 2. C: −2 < a/b < 1. D: ab − 2 < a − 2b.

Question

Given 2<a<1-2<a<1 and 1<b<21<b<2, which of the following are correct?

A. 4<ab<0-4<a-b<0

B. 2<ab<2-2<ab<2

C. 2<ab<1-2<\dfrac{a}{b}<1

D. ab2<a2bab-2<a-2b

Step-by-step solution

  1. Fix the correct rule for subtraction. Inequalities may be added but not subtracted directly; instead negate the second one first. From 1<b<21<b<2 we get 2<b<1-2<-b<-1, and adding to 2<a<1-2<a<1 gives

    4<ab<0-4<a-b<0

    So A is correct, and the bounds are sharp (approached as a2,b2a\to-2,b\to 2 and as a1,b1a\to 1,b\to 1).

  2. B is wrong — check the extreme corners of the product. Because aa can be negative, the extremes of abab occur at the corners of the rectangle: abab ranges over (2)(2)=4(-2)(2)=-4 up to (1)(2)=2(1)(2)=2, so

    4<ab<2-4<ab<2

    Values below 2-2 really occur: a=1.8a=-1.8, b=1.9b=1.9 gives ab=3.42ab=-3.42. Incorrect.

  3. C is correct. Since b>0b>0, dividing preserves directions and the quotient is largest when aa is largest and bb smallest, smallest when aa is most negative and bb smallest:

    ab>21=2,ab<11=1\frac{a}{b}>\frac{-2}{1}=-2,\qquad \frac{a}{b}<\frac{1}{1}=1

    so 2<ab<1-2<\dfrac ab<1. Correct.

  4. D is wrong — rearrange into a product. The claim ab2<a2bab-2<a-2b is equivalent to

    aba+2b2<0a(b1)+2(b1)<0(a+2)(b1)<0ab-a+2b-2<0\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad a(b-1)+2(b-1)<0\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad (a+2)(b-1)<0

    But a>2a>-2 gives a+2>0a+2>0, and b>1b>1 gives b1>0b-1>0, so the product is positive for every allowed pair. The stated inequality is therefore always false. Incorrect.

  5. Conclude and verify with a sample point.

    A and C\boxed{\text{A and C}}

    Take a=0a=0, b=1.5b=1.5: ab=1.5(4,0)a-b=-1.5\in(-4,0) ✓; ab=0(4,2)ab=0\in(-4,2) (and also in (2,2)(-2,2), which is why B needs a corner test to disprove); a/b=0(2,1)a/b=0\in(-2,1) ✓; and ab2=2ab-2=-2 versus a2b=3a-2b=-3, so 2<3-2<-3 is false ✓, confirming D fails.

Answer

A and C\text{A and C}

Need to solve a different problem like this? Open the solver →