Trigonometry · real student question

Determine whether each of the following is possible for a real number m: cos(m) = 2, tan(m) = 2, cot(0) = m, csc(pi) = m, sin(m) = -1.1, arcsec(m) = pi/2, cot(pi) = m, sin(m) = -0.9.

Question

Determine whether each of the following is possible for a real number mm.

a. cos(m)=2\cos(m)=2 b. tan(m)=2\tan(m)=2 c. cot(0)=m\cot(0)=m d. csc(π)=m\csc(\pi)=m

e. sin(m)=1.1\sin(m)=-1.1 f. sec1(m)=π2\sec^{-1}(m)=\tfrac{\pi}{2} g. cot(π)=m\cot(\pi)=m h. sin(m)=0.9\sin(m)=-0.9

Step-by-step solution

  1. Sort the eight statements into two kinds. In (a), (b), (e) and (h) the unknown is inside the function, so the question is whether the given output lies in the function's range. In (c), (d) and (g) the unknown is the output, so the question is whether the function is even defined at that input. Part (f) is about the range of an inverse function.

  2. Use the range of sine and cosine for (a), (e) and (h). For every real mm,

    1sinm1,1cosm1.-1\le\sin m\le 1,\qquad -1\le\cos m\le 1.

    So cos(m)=2\cos(m)=2 is not possible and sin(m)=1.1\sin(m)=-1.1 is not possible, while sin(m)=0.9\sin(m)=-0.9 is possible (for instance m=arcsin(0.9)1.1198m=\arcsin(-0.9)\approx-1.1198).

  3. Use the range of tangent for (b). tan\tan takes every real value on each branch, so tan(m)=2\tan(m)=2 is possible; m=arctan21.1071m=\arctan 2\approx 1.1071 works, as do m1.1071+kπm\approx 1.1071+k\pi.

  4. Check where cotangent and cosecant blow up, for (c), (d) and (g). Both have sin\sin in the denominator:

    cotθ=cosθsinθ,cscθ=1sinθ.\cot\theta=\frac{\cos\theta}{\sin\theta},\qquad \csc\theta=\frac{1}{\sin\theta}.

    Since sin0=0\sin 0=0 and sinπ=0\sin\pi=0, all three of cot(0)\cot(0), csc(π)\csc(\pi) and cot(π)\cot(\pi) are undefined — they are 10\tfrac10, 10\tfrac10 and 10\tfrac{-1}{0}. No real mm can equal an undefined expression, so (c), (d) and (g) are not possible.

  5. Check the range of inverse secant for (f). The inverse secant is defined with range [0,π2)(π2,π]\left[0,\tfrac{\pi}{2}\right)\cup\left(\tfrac{\pi}{2},\pi\right] — the value π2\tfrac{\pi}{2} is deliberately excluded, because sec(π2)=1cos(π/2)=10\sec\left(\tfrac{\pi}{2}\right)=\tfrac{1}{\cos(\pi/2)}=\tfrac10 is undefined. So sec1(m)=π2\sec^{-1}(m)=\tfrac{\pi}{2} is not possible.

  6. Collect the verdicts. Possible: (b) and (h). Not possible: (a), (c), (d), (e), (f), (g). The pattern worth remembering is that bounded functions fail on size, and reciprocal functions fail wherever their denominator hits zero.

Answer

Possible: (b) tanm=2, (h) sinm=0.9; all others are impossible\text{Possible: (b) }\tan m=2,\ \text{(h) }\sin m=-0.9;\ \text{all others are impossible}

Need to solve a different problem like this? Open the solver →