Statistics · real student question

In a mathematics class, half of the students scored 92 on an achievement test. With the exception of a few students who scored 54, the remaining students scored 73. Which statement about the distribution is true?

Question

In a mathematics class, half of the students scored 9292 on an achievement test. With the exception of a few students who scored 5454, the remaining students scored 7373. Which of the following is true about the distribution of scores?

A. The mean is greater than the mode.
B. The mean and the median are the same.
C. The mean is less than the median.
D. The mean is greater than the median.

Step-by-step solution

  1. Introduce counts. Let NN be the (even) class size: N2\tfrac{N}{2} students scored 9292, k1k \ge 1 students scored 5454, and N2k\tfrac{N}{2} - k scored 7373. Treating "a few" as an unknown kk keeps the argument valid for every reading of the word.

  2. Find the median. In ascending order the first kk values are 5454, the next N2k\tfrac{N}{2} - k are 7373, and the top N2\tfrac{N}{2} are 9292. Position N2\tfrac{N}{2} therefore holds 7373 and position N2+1\tfrac{N}{2}+1 holds 9292, so

    median=73+922=82.5\text{median} = \frac{73 + 92}{2} = 82.5

    again independent of kk.

  3. Compute the mean.

    mean=92N2+54k+73(N2k)N=82.5N19kN=82.519kN\text{mean} = \frac{92\cdot\tfrac{N}{2} + 54k + 73\left(\tfrac{N}{2} - k\right)}{N} = \frac{82.5N - 19k}{N} = 82.5 - \frac{19k}{N}

  4. Compare the two. With k1k \ge 1 the correction 19kN-\tfrac{19k}{N} is strictly negative:

    mean=82.519kN<82.5=median\text{mean} = 82.5 - \frac{19k}{N} < 82.5 = \text{median}

    The distribution is skewed left — a small tail well below the bulk pulls the mean down without moving the median. Option C is correct.

  5. Check the other options. B is false since the mean is strictly below 82.582.5. D reverses the inequality. A is false too: the mode is 9292 (half the class), and the mean is at most 82.582.5, so the mean is less than the mode, not greater.

  6. Verify with numbers. N=20N = 20, k=3k = 3: ten 9292s, three 5454s, seven 7373s give mean 920+162+51120=79.65\tfrac{920 + 162 + 511}{20} = 79.65 against median 82.582.5. N=100N = 100, k=7k = 7: mean 81.1781.17, median 82.582.5. Both agree with 82.519kN82.5 - \tfrac{19k}{N}.

Answer

C. The mean is less than the median(mean=82.519kN, median=82.5)\text{C. The mean is less than the median}\quad\left(\text{mean} = 82.5 - \tfrac{19k}{N},\ \text{median} = 82.5\right)

Need to solve a different problem like this? Open the solver →