Calculus · real student question

Find all real m for which y = (x + 4)/(x + m) is increasing on the interval (−∞, −7).

Question

Find the set of all real values of mm for which

y=x+4x+my=\frac{x+4}{x+m}

is increasing on the interval (,7)(-\infty,-7).

Step-by-step solution

  1. Differentiate using the Möbius formula. For y=ax+bcx+dy=\dfrac{ax+b}{cx+d} we have y=adbc(cx+d)2y'=\dfrac{ad-bc}{(cx+d)^{2}}, and here a=1a=1, b=4b=4, c=1c=1, d=md=m:

    y=m4(x+m)2y'=\frac{m-4}{(x+m)^{2}}

  2. Impose the sign condition. The squared denominator is positive wherever yy is defined, so increasing means

    m4>0m>4m-4>0\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad m>4

  3. Impose the pole condition. The function has a vertical asymptote at x=mx=-m. Increasing on the whole interval (,7)(-\infty,-7) requires that asymptote to lie outside it:

    m(,7)m7m7-m\notin(-\infty,-7)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad -m\ge -7\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad m\le 7

    Note the endpoint is allowed: at m=7m=7 the pole sits exactly at x=7x=-7, which is not an interior point of the open interval (,7)(-\infty,-7).

  4. Intersect the two conditions.

    4<m74<m\le 7

    m(4,7]\boxed{m\in(4,\,7]}

  5. Test the three boundary cases. At m=4m=4: y=x+4x+4=1y=\tfrac{x+4}{x+4}=1, a constant — not increasing ✗, so 44 is excluded. At m=7m=7: y=x+4x+7y=\tfrac{x+4}{x+7} with y=3(x+7)2>0y'=\tfrac{3}{(x+7)^{2}}>0 on (,7)(-\infty,-7) ✓, so 77 is included. At m=8m=8: the pole x=8x=-8 lies inside (,7)(-\infty,-7), so the function has a break there and is not increasing across the whole interval ✗.

  6. Note the pattern. For y=x+px+my=\dfrac{x+p}{x+m} increasing on (,q)(-\infty,-q) with q>p>0q>p>0, the same two conditions give p<mqp<m\le q — so the answer is always the half-open interval (p,q](p,q], closed at the right end.

Answer

m(4,7]m\in(4,\,7]

Need to solve a different problem like this? Open the solver →