Algebra · real student question

Factor x^3 - 5x^2 + 3x + 2, or show that it does not factor over the rationals, and find its real roots.

Question

Factor

x35x2+3x+2x^3-5x^2+3x+2

over the rationals, or show that it cannot be factored, and locate its real roots.

Step-by-step solution

  1. List the candidate rational roots. By the Rational Root Theorem, a rational root pq\tfrac{p}{q} in lowest terms has pp dividing the constant 22 and qq dividing the leading coefficient 11. So q=±1q=\pm1 and the only candidates are

    x=±1, ±2x=\pm1,\ \pm2

  2. Test every candidate.

    f(1)=15+3+2=1,f(1)=153+2=7f(1)=1-5+3+2=1,\qquad f(-1)=-1-5-3+2=-7

    f(2)=820+6+2=4,f(2)=8206+2=32f(2)=8-20+6+2=-4,\qquad f(-2)=-8-20-6+2=-32

    None is zero, so there is no rational root and hence no linear factor with rational coefficients. A cubic factors over Q\mathbb{Q} only if it has a rational root (any factorisation must include a linear piece), so this cubic is irreducible over Q\mathbb{Q}.

  3. Do not confuse irreducible with rootless. A real cubic always has at least one real root, because it runs from -\infty to ++\infty continuously. "Does not factor over the rationals" says nothing about real roots — it only says none of them is a fraction.

  4. Count the real roots with sign changes. Evaluate at a few points: f(1)=7f(-1)=-7, f(0)=+2f(0)=+2, f(1)=+1f(1)=+1, f(2)=4f(2)=-4, f(5)=+17f(5)=+17. The sign changes between 1-1 and 00, between 11 and 22, and between 22 and 55three sign changes, so all three roots are real and irrational.

  5. Locate them numerically. Bisecting on a fine grid over [10,10][-10,10]:

    x10.3914,x21.2271,x34.1642x_1\approx-0.3914,\qquad x_2\approx1.2271,\qquad x_3\approx4.1642

    So the real factorisation is (x+0.3914)(x1.2271)(x4.1642)(x+0.3914)(x-1.2271)(x-4.1642) to four decimals — perfectly valid over R\mathbb{R}, just not over Q\mathbb{Q}.

  6. Check with Vieta's formulas. The roots should sum to b/a=5-b/a=5: 0.3914+1.2271+4.1642=4.9999-0.3914+1.2271+4.1642=4.9999 ✓, and their product should be d/a=2-d/a=-2: (0.3914)(1.2271)(4.1642)=2.0000(-0.3914)(1.2271)(4.1642)=-2.0000 ✓. Both agree to grid accuracy, confirming that three real roots have been found and none was missed.

Answer

Irreducible over Q (no rational root); three real irrational roots x0.3913, 1.2272, 4.1643\text{Irreducible over }\mathbb{Q}\text{ (no rational root); three real irrational roots } x\approx-0.3913,\ 1.2272,\ 4.1643

Need to solve a different problem like this? Open the solver →