Algebra · real student question

Solve the quintic equation 40x^5 - 51x^4 + 10 = 0.

Question

Solve

40x551x4+10=040x^5 - 51x^4 + 10 = 0

Step-by-step solution

  1. Rule out rational roots. Candidates are ±de\pm\tfrac{d}{e} with d10d \mid 10 and e40e \mid 40. Spot checks: f(1)=1f(1) = -1, f(1)=81f(-1) = -81, f ⁣(12)=12916=8.0625f\!\left(\tfrac12\right) = \tfrac{129}{16} = 8.0625, f ⁣(12)=8916=5.5625f\!\left(-\tfrac12\right) = \tfrac{89}{16} = 5.5625, f ⁣(54)=7.5586f\!\left(\tfrac54\right) = 7.5586. None vanish, and by Abel–Ruffini a general quintic has no radical solution, so the roots must be located numerically.

  2. Bracket the real roots by sign changes. Tabulating f(x)=40x551x4+10f(x) = 40x^5 - 51x^4 + 10:

    f(1)=81,f(0.7)=8.968,f(0.5)=5.563,f(0)=10,f(0.9)=0.159,f(1)=1,f(1.1)=0.249,f(1.2)=3.779f(-1) = -81, \quad f(-0.7) = -8.968, \quad f(-0.5) = 5.563, \quad f(0) = 10, \quad f(0.9) = 0.159, \quad f(1) = -1, \quad f(1.1) = -0.249, \quad f(1.2) = 3.779

    Each sign change traps a root: one in (0.7,0.5)(-0.7,\,-0.5), one in (0.9,1)(0.9,\,1), and one in (1.1,1.2)(1.1,\,1.2). Since ff \to -\infty as xx \to -\infty and f+f \to +\infty as x+x \to +\infty, these three are all the real roots.

  3. Refine each bracket. Bisection or Newton on each interval converges to

    x10.603957,x20.909281,x31.110778x_1 \approx -0.603957, \qquad x_2 \approx 0.909281, \qquad x_3 \approx 1.110778

  4. Recover the remaining conjugate pair. A quintic has five roots. Deflating by the three real ones leaves a quadratic whose roots are

    x0.070551±0.636284ix \approx -0.070551 \pm 0.636284\,i

  5. Verify with the coefficient relations. The sum of all five roots must be 5140=1.275\tfrac{51}{40} = 1.275: 0.603957+0.909281+1.110778+2(0.070551)=1.275000-0.603957 + 0.909281 + 1.110778 + 2(-0.070551) = 1.275000. The product must be 1040=0.25-\tfrac{10}{40} = -0.25 (degree 5, so the sign flips): (0.603957)(0.909281)(1.110778)(0.0705512+0.6362842)=0.250000(-0.603957)(0.909281)(1.110778)\left(0.070551^2 + 0.636284^2\right) = -0.250000. Direct substitution gives f(xi)<1012|f(x_i)| < 10^{-12} for each real root.

  6. A warning about widely circulated wrong values. The triple 0.6487, 0.7606, 1.2264-0.6487,\ 0.7606,\ 1.2264 is sometimes quoted for this equation, but f(0.6487)=3.63f(-0.6487) = -3.63, f(0.7606)=3.11f(0.7606) = 3.11 and f(1.2264)=5.60f(1.2264) = 5.60 — none of them is a root.

Answer

x0.603957, 0.909281, 1.110778,x0.070551±0.636284ix \approx -0.603957,\ 0.909281,\ 1.110778, \qquad x \approx -0.070551 \pm 0.636284\,i

Need to solve a different problem like this? Open the solver →