Algebra · real student question

Solve 1/(s + 2) + 1/(s + 4) + 1/(s + 9) - 1/(s + 6) = 0 for s.

Question

Solve for ss:

1s+2+1s+4+1s+91s+6=0\frac{1}{s+2}+\frac{1}{s+4}+\frac{1}{s+9}-\frac{1}{s+6}=0

Step-by-step solution

  1. Record the excluded values first. The four denominators vanish at

    s=2, 4, 6, 9s=-2,\ -4,\ -6,\ -9

    None of these can be a solution, whatever the algebra produces. Noting them up front means any spurious root that appears later is caught immediately.

  2. Clear the denominators by multiplying through. Multiplying every term by (s+2)(s+4)(s+6)(s+9)(s+2)(s+4)(s+6)(s+9) turns the equation into a polynomial one. Collecting the four resulting cubics gives

    2s3+33s2+180s+300=02s^{3}+33s^{2}+180s+300=0

    The quartic terms cancel because three fractions are added and one is subtracted, dropping the degree from 4 to 3.

  3. Test for rational roots — and reject the tempting ones. By the rational root theorem the candidates are ±pq\pm\frac{p}{q} with p300p\mid 300 and q2q\mid 2. Checking the plausible ones: s=5s=-5 gives 2(125)+33(25)900+300=2502(-125)+33(25)-900+300=-25\neq 0, s=4s=-4 gives 128+528720+300=200-128+528-720+300=-20\neq 0, and s=152s=-\tfrac{15}{2} gives 33754+742541350+3000-\tfrac{3375}{4}+\tfrac{7425}{4}-1350+300\neq 0. No rational root exists, so the cubic does not factor over the rationals.

  4. Always expand a proposed factorisation. A guess such as (s+5)(2s+15)(s+4)(s+5)(2s+15)(s+4) multiplies out to 2s3+33s2+175s+3002s^{3}+33s^{2}+175s+300 — it matches the leading, quadratic and constant coefficients but the linear one is 175175, not 180180. Checking that single coefficient is what exposes the error.

  5. Find the real root numerically. Since f(3)=3>0f(-3)=3>0 and f(3.1)=0.452<0f(-3.1)=-0.452<0, a root lies between them; Newton iteration converges to

    s3.0864085s\approx-3.0864085

    This is not one of the excluded values, so it is a genuine solution.

  6. Account for the other two roots and verify. The remaining roots are the complex pair s6.7068±1.9024is\approx-6.7068\pm 1.9024i, so there is exactly one real solution. Substituting s=3.0864085s=-3.0864085 back: 11.0864+10.9136+15.913612.9136=0.9205+1.0946+0.16910.3432=0.0000\tfrac{1}{-1.0864}+\tfrac{1}{0.9136}+\tfrac{1}{5.9136}-\tfrac{1}{2.9136}=-0.9205+1.0946+0.1691-0.3432=0.0000 ✓.

Answer

s3.0864085(the only real solution)s\approx-3.0864085\quad\text{(the only real solution)}

Need to solve a different problem like this? Open the solver →