Algebra · real student question

Solve 3^x = x^9 for real x.

Question

Solve

3x=x93^{x}=x^{9}

for real xx.

Step-by-step solution

  1. Restrict the domain using the left side. 3x>03^{x}>0 for every real xx, so x9x^{9} must be positive too. Since 99 is odd, x9>0x^{9}>0 forces

    x>0x>0

    so only positive xx need be considered — and the logarithm is then legal.

  2. Take logarithms to turn both sides into products. For x>0x>0:

    xln3=9lnxlnxx=ln390.122068x\ln3=9\ln x\qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad\frac{\ln x}{x}=\frac{\ln3}{9}\approx0.122068

    The problem has become: where does the curve g(x)=lnxxg(x)=\dfrac{\ln x}{x} hit a fixed horizontal level?

  3. Spot the exact root. Try to make both sides a power of the same base. Since 27=3327=3^{3},

    279=(33)9=327 27^{9}=\left(3^{3}\right)^{9}=3^{27}\ \checkmark

    so x=27x=27 solves the equation exactly — verified in exact integer arithmetic ✓. (By contrast x=9x=9 fails: 39=196833^{9}=19683 but 99=3874204899^{9}=387\,420\,489, and x=3x=3 fails too.)

  4. Count the roots from the shape of gg. Differentiating, g(x)=1lnxx2g'(x)=\dfrac{1-\ln x}{x^{2}}, which is positive for x<ex<e and negative for x>ex>e. So gg rises to a single maximum g(e)=1/e0.3679g(e)=1/e\approx0.3679 and then decreases to 00. Since the target level 0.1220680.122068 is below that maximum and above 00, the horizontal line cuts the curve exactly twice — once on each side of x=ex=e. The known root 2727 lies to the right, so a second root must lie in (1,e)(1,e).

  5. Locate the second root numerically. Bisecting g(x)=ln3/9g(x)=\ln3/9 on (1,e)(1,e) converges to

    x1.1508248x\approx1.1508248

    Check: 31.1508248=3.54064993^{1.1508248}=3.5406499 and 1.15082489=3.54064991.1508248^{9}=3.5406499 ✓, agreeing to 101310^{-13}. So the equation has two real solutions — reporting only x=27x=27 misses half the answer:

    x=27andx1.15082x=27\qquad\text{and}\qquad x\approx1.15082

Answer

x=27andx1.15082x=27\quad\text{and}\quad x\approx1.15082

Need to solve a different problem like this? Open the solver →