Algebra · real student question

Determine whether f(x) = x sqrt(x + 9) is even, odd, or neither - algebraically, graphically, and numerically by comparing f(x) with f(-x).

Question

Determine whether the function

f(x)=xx+9f(x) = x\sqrt{x+9}

is even, odd, or neither — algebraically, graphically, and numerically by comparing f(x)f(x) with f(x)f(-x) for several values of xx.

Step-by-step solution

  1. Recall the two tests. ff is even if f(x)=f(x)f(-x) = f(x) for all xx in the domain (symmetry about the yy-axis), and odd if f(x)=f(x)f(-x) = -f(x) (symmetry about the origin). If neither identity holds everywhere, the answer is "neither" — and most functions are neither.

  2. Check the domain first. The radicand must satisfy x+90x + 9 \ge 0, so the domain is [9,)[-9, \infty). This interval is not symmetric about 00: x=20x = 20 is in the domain but x=20x = -20 is not. For an even or odd function the domain has to be symmetric, so this observation alone already forces the answer, before any algebra.

  3. Compute f(x)f(-x) algebraically. Replace xx by x-x everywhere:

    f(x)=(x)x+9=x9xf(-x) = (-x)\sqrt{-x+9} = -x\sqrt{9-x}

    Compare with f(x)=xx+9f(x) = x\sqrt{x+9} and f(x)=xx+9-f(x) = -x\sqrt{x+9}. The radicals differ — 9x\sqrt{9-x} versus x+9\sqrt{x+9} — so f(x)f(-x) equals neither one.

  4. Confirm numerically. Evaluate at two symmetric pairs:

    xxf(x)f(x)
    111103.161\sqrt{10} \approx 3.16
    1-1182.83-1\sqrt{8} \approx -2.83
    4441314.424\sqrt{13} \approx 14.42
    4-4458.94-4\sqrt{5} \approx -8.94

    If ff were even we would need f(1)=f(1)f(-1) = f(1), but 2.833.16-2.83 \neq 3.16. If ff were odd we would need f(1)=f(1)=3.16f(-1) = -f(1) = -3.16, but f(1)=2.83f(-1) = -2.83. Both fail, and the ±4\pm 4 pair fails the same way.

  5. Read the graph the same way. The curve starts at (9,0)(-9, 0), dips to a minimum near x=6x = -6, and rises without bound to the right; there is nothing to the left of x=9x = -9. So it is symmetric neither about the yy-axis nor about the origin.

  6. Conclude. All three tests agree: f(x)=xx+9f(x) = x\sqrt{x+9} is neither even nor odd. The near-miss is instructive — xx2+9x\sqrt{x^2+9} would be odd, because squaring xx makes the radicand immune to the sign change.

Answer

Neither even nor odd\text{Neither even nor odd}

Need to solve a different problem like this? Open the solver →