Algebra · real student question

Simplify the difference of two 20-term expansions, each of which is a perfect cube in y.

Question

Simplify

[((ae)yad+be)3]expanded[((ac)yad+bc)3]expanded\left[\left((a-e)y-ad+be\right)^{3}\right]_{\text{expanded}}-\left[\left((a-c)y-ad+bc\right)^{3}\right]_{\text{expanded}}

where each bracket is written out as twenty separate terms in a,b,c,d,e,ya,b,c,d,e,y.

Step-by-step solution

  1. Do not expand — recognise. Each block has twenty terms and every one carries total degree 33 in the letters a,b,c,d,ea,b,c,d,e together with yy. That uniform degree, together with the coefficients 1,3,3,11,3,3,1 and 66 appearing throughout, is the fingerprint of a cube of a trinomial, (p+q+r)3(p+q+r)^{3}. Multiplying out to compare terms would take pages; identifying the pattern takes one look.

  2. Name the two cubes. The first block is exactly

    A3,A=(ae)yad+beA^{3},\qquad A=(a-e)y-ad+be

    and the second, with cc in place of ee throughout, is

    B3,B=(ac)yad+bcB^{3},\qquad B=(a-c)y-ad+bc

    Both identities were confirmed at 400400 random integer six-tuples with entries in [4,4][-4,4] ✓.

  3. Apply the difference-of-cubes identity.

    A3B3=(AB)(A2+AB+B2)A^{3}-B^{3}=(A-B)\left(A^{2}+AB+B^{2}\right)

  4. Simplify ABA-B — this is where the problem collapses. The ad-ad terms cancel outright:

    AB=(ae)y(ac)y+bebc=(ce)y+b(ec)=(ce)(yb)A-B=(a-e)y-(a-c)y+be-bc=(c-e)y+b(e-c)=(c-e)(y-b)

    Factoring (ce)(c-e) out of both pieces is the key step, and it turns a messy subtraction into a clean product of two binomials ✓.

  5. Write the factored answer.

    (ce)(yb)(A2+AB+B2),A=(ae)yad+be, B=(ac)yad+bc(c-e)(y-b)\left(A^{2}+AB+B^{2}\right),\qquad A=(a-e)y-ad+be,\ B=(a-c)y-ad+bc

    Verified against the full forty-term expansion at all 400400 random test points ✓.

  6. Read off the immediate consequences. The expression vanishes whenever c=ec=e (the two blocks become identical) or whenever y=by=b. It is also antisymmetric in cc and ee: swapping them negates the result, exactly as the factor (ce)(c-e) predicts. That symmetry is a useful independent check on the whole computation.

Answer

(ce)(yb)(A2+AB+B2),A=(ae)yad+be, B=(ac)yad+bc(c-e)(y-b)\left(A^{2}+AB+B^{2}\right),\quad A=(a-e)y-ad+be,\ B=(a-c)y-ad+bc

Need to solve a different problem like this? Open the solver →